I have a couple of pet peeves that have been aggravated this week. Pet peeve number 1 is email forwards that are factually incorrect. Someone has an agenda, usually political, and they forward something inflammatory without any regard for the truth. I only ever receive these from Christians. Maybe unbelievers do it too. But it bothers me deeply when Christians sin against such a clear Scriptural command (after all, not bearing false witness is one of the 10 Commandments) in their own moral outrage over something that often Scripture doesn’t address at all.
I guess this first pet peeve is just a sub point of my next one, which is dogmatism over something that the Scripture is not dogmatic. Dogma is doctrine laid down by an authority. Dogma is a very good thing when the authority laying it down is the Scripture. To be dogmatic means to assert strong opinions on dogma in an arrogant manner. Dogma is one thing. Dogmatism is another. And dogmatism is especially dishonoring to God when the dogma we are arrogantly defending is not laid down in Scripture at all. We do this ALL THE TIME in conservative Christianity.
I’m currently contemplating political dogmatism dressed in Christian terminology. The moral outrage Christians generate over political issues, at least in my culture, is loud and angry. Every third rainy Tuesday or so, the angst is tied to something Scripture actually dogmatically teaches. But the vast majority of the time, at least in my experience, the angst is over something the individual perceives as righteous or unrighteous but that Scripture itself only addresses in either very general terms or doesn’t address at all.
My convictions about the relationship of my Christian beliefs to my political beliefs are fairly simple. My clear, God given obligation is to pray for my leaders (I Timothy 2:1-2) and obey the laws of my land (Romans 13:1). That is Scriptural dogma. Beyond that, I have a realistic understanding of the role that government plays in my life. I certainly have no expectation that government will save me. I also don’t believe that it will destroy me, if I define that Biblically. God’s kingdom functions equally well in religious freedom and religious oppression (arguably actually better in oppression). I am daily thankful for my religious freedom, but it won’t save me. The power people give the government to ruin their day is amazing to me. It has become a god – usually a mean god that ruins their day, but a god nonetheless.
Of course, it’s easy for me to talk today. Government is not knocking on my door requiring anything oppressive from me. I have had a few times (mostly driving tickets that I thought were unreasonable and 1 presidential election that stressed me out in particular) where government made me mad and I felt angst and anger out of proportion to the power they truly have over me in terms of God’s kingdom. These times raised my awareness of the power I gave it to ruin my day. I encourage all of us to examine our reactions to political issues – our angst, our anger, our worry – and hold those reactions up to eternal Biblical truth. Does your reaction reflect confidence in God’s eternal kingdom purposes? Do you trust God when He says He sets up your leaders (Romans 13:1)? Do you believe that God is sovereign over even oppressive governments? Do you allow yourself to violate clear Scriptural commands (such as against malice or lying) in defense of your political views? Do you love those who have different political views? Using the I Corinthians 13 definition of love, do you speak rudely to those with a different view or do you give them the benefit of the doubt? Are you kind and patient in your disagreements? Or do you write them off losing hope for anything good?
This blog is read among many countries. For many of you, this may be a non-issue. But if you are experiencing angst, anger, and worry over your government’s decisions, I hope you will take time to examine them against what Scripture clearly states in dogmatic terms. And make sure your dogmatism matches Scripture.
Tuesday, March 23, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
21 comments:
Amen.
I like this post. I often get inflammatory emails that I can disprove in about 20 minutes of research. In addition, it frustrates me that many Christians waste so much time slandering and railing against political figures and agendas. I know countless people that spend tons of time campaigning against candidates that support the right to choose an abortion or some other hot button topic but would never spend time actually doing anything that might prevent someone from thinking they need to get an abortion. I feel like the Christian community is blaming all our moral failures on the government instead of trying to really do something about them.
I agree with the AMEN!
Well said ... and much needed. Thank you.
Ahh good old email forwards. Some Christians seem to turn off their brains when they open their emails. Here it tends to be more of the "forward this to 20 people and you'll get a free laptop" type of insanity than the political variety.
I wish more American Christians would do reading about the political situations around the world and realise that for all the American systems faults, they really do have it pretty good.
Thank you.
This is so good. I linked to it on my FB page.
I love you, Wendy Alsup. My best friend and I were discussing this very topic yesterday, and we share your frustration. Thank you for this clear, biblical perspecitive on such a messy topic.
Thank you! This has been a frustrating week because of just what you said.
Too bad this is "Practical Theology for Women" otherwise I'd post a link to this on my Facebook page! (Because I'm a dude.)
Coffeeaddict, live life on the edge, dude! :-)
Thank you! You have encouraged me to believe that there are sane believers after all! I was in a deep discussion today about WWJD and I finally had enough and had to conclude that He might have been called a socialist in this environment we live in.
I'm thinking of a new acronym. HWJR -- How Would Jesus React?
Excellent. For those emails and "forwards" that come my way from well meaning believers (and that includes the biggest offender who happens to be my mother) there is the delete button.
Christians in politics = good. Political Christianity = bad.
I appreciate the post.
"Of course, it’s easy for me to talk today. Government is not knocking on my door requiring anything oppressive from me."
Not today, but it is coming. From a guy’s perspective, as a protector of my family, I guess this is why it is so passionate for me. It isn't about politics, it is about my children not having to fight the righteous battles I should have fought.
"Does your reaction reflect confidence in God’s eternal kingdom purposes? Do you trust God when He says He sets up your leaders (Romans 13:1)? Do you believe that God is sovereign over even oppressive governments?"
Yes...great questions...although you should be careful to not equate (peaceful, vigorous) opposition to the government in our democracy to be unworthy of Believers. And, remember, our heros, from Biblical ones to historical ones are normally those who took on the powers of their times.
Our hero is Jesus. And His prayer from the cross as He was crucified by His government was, "Father, forgive them for they know not what they do." I'm not arguing against a principled stand against government, as long as it is consistent with clear Biblical guidelines for righteous behavior. Don't lie. Don't harbor malice. Don't be rude. Give the benefit of the doubt.
I seriously doubt that Jesus would have been a socialist. He would not have been democratic, nor republican, nor dictatorial, nor monarchical, nor any other form of government under the sun except theocratic. In fact, Jesus purposefully spoke to the individual's relationship with God above all else. The Sermon on the Mount is meant for individuals, not for government. Someone posted Christians in politics = good. Political Christianity = not good. The Catholic Church tried this approach, and it didn't work for many reasons...the most obvious being human failure when it comes to the conglomeration of power. However, we have many examples from the Scripture of men and women who were believers involved with the governments of their day. The Scripture says that we are to be as wise as serpents and as harmless as doves, and this should be applied to our understanding of the historical context of current politics.
Thanks for the insight, I hadn't considered this perspective and its quite a good one. You made my day.
Good post, Wendy! I pray that Christians will pay attention to the truths you stated here. I believe this is a huge blind-spot for many believers today. May God open the eyes of His people in this area of politics... for His glory! I have posted similar thoughts over at my blog. I would love to re-post this post [giving you the credit for writing it, of course ;)]and then include a link to your blog. Would I have your permission to re-post this on my blog or would you rather I only link to your blog for people to read the post here?
Thanks!
www.dea-frommyhearttoyours.blogspot.com
Either is fine with me. Thanks for asking! Glad it resonated with you.
Post a Comment